By week 3 of the project (a quarter of the way through the pre-production segment), I was beginning to get a little worried about the project. I was clear that no one would be joining the group, and my project might not be achievable by one person in the allotted production timeframe of twelve weeks. Fortunately, our tutors offer tutorial slots outside of lessons for one-to-one discussions of our work, so I took what I had so far to Dave Surman for his opinions and hopefully some ideas on where to take the project.
Overall, he was pleased with the project’s edutainment objective, but strongly recommended I reconsider my stylistic approach, fearing again that the detailed environment would detract from the political message within. As he explained, I had convinced myself that the only options art-style wise were either anime or realism, which was simply not the case, and the project had great scope for a really interesting stylistic approach even with the restriction of it being a lone project.
He took notice of the propaganda poster idea that was to be one of the smaller segments, and he put forward the suggestion of reapplying a propaganda art style to the project as a whole; in most cases stylised with very simple shapes (much like Lucky star, which I referenced in an earlier post) and commonly using symbolic rather than realistic objects (such as a monster to represent an evil human). The level therefore did not need to necessarily resemble a true world; buildings could merely be blocks, or even floating platforms linked by ramps. A tank could be oversized to gigantic proportions to make it more imposing, and covered in propaganda artwork, becoming more of a gesture of political extremist will than a vehicle. Helicopters could be shrunk to the size of bees and buzz around the player annoyingly.
We both felt these would suit a one-person project well, and he explained that it would further focus attention onto the message. He recommended the Soviet Union, which was well known for its powerful propaganda machine, to be a good starting point for my research.
A Quick pen sketch by Dave to demonstrate how human form is presented stoically in traditional Soviet-esque propaganda pieces, with sharp angles, straight lines and strong contrasts of light and dark (which was an aspect of art I had previously expressed interest in).
Happy with the ideas put forward, I have finally decided that I will go ahead with the project alone; the new style devised by Dave and myself is far more achievable by one person, and no other members of the year are available to join up by this time anyway; all are in groups, and those groups are well into development and have no real space for new members.
* * *
Using the University Library and the Internet, I was able to piece together a timeline of important events in the history of Soviet propaganda, and gather several examples of artists and their works.
Propaganda was a centre point in Soviet politics from the very beginning; 1917 when Russian Communism first began its uprising against Imperial rule. It was considered a vital method of reaching the soviet people; it was easily understood, memorable, quickly made and replicated, and did not require much knowledge of literacy (which some communities in Russia at the time lacked). The founding fathers were three men. The first, Alexander Apsit, an icon painter and allegorical artist, began work in 1918 and is most famous for having designed the ‘hammer and sickle’ and ‘red star’ icons used to represent the Soviet Union, and now widely applied in communisms worldwide.
Apsit's Hammer and Sickle and Red Star icons; used as insignia's of the Soviet Union (the Goverment and the army, respectively), and commonly found in many communist nations.
The second and third, respectively, were Dimitri Moor and Victor Deni, who both started in 1919. Moor was trained as a satirical artist, and, despite his atheism, was highly interested in the iconography of religious artwork (looking more at the form, colour and emotions of the art itself than off the ideology it represented). His propaganda work set the standards for works that followed, focusing on strong, contrasting colours (most commonly red, black and white). Victor Deni’s specialty was in the field of caricature, drawing depictions of existing or fictional figures that conveyed particular opinions (such as the obese, top-hatted cartoon character below, used by Deni to symbolise capitalism, which was considered the enemy in Communist ideology).
Examples of Dimitri Moor's work. Note the simplicity of the colour scheme and blocky shapes.
Examples of Victor Deni's work, depicting the "obsese capitalist" icon he designed.
In most art pieces, communist citizens (usually represented by a blacksmith or labourer) were commonly given strong, stoic poses, designed to create the look almost of a stone statue. Depicted opponents, on the other hand, were usually depicted in grotesque or even inhuman forms, so as to alienate Soviet citizens from the concept of them as fellow human beings; they were monsters seeking to crush the Union.
Soviet postet use was taken further during the 20s by the concept of ROSTA posters, created by a team led by poet Vladimir Mayakovsky and artist Mikhail Cheremnych. These were designed to be posted on shop windows, and aimed to educate Soviet people on general knowledge deemed beneficial, such as tips for healthy living. Though more colourful than Moor’s designs, ROSTA maintained the practice of simple, generally blocky shapes.
Example of a ROSTA poster, by Mayakovsky and Cheremnych.
The same was true in El Lissitsky and Alexander Rodchenko’s work in the Post-World War 1 period, around the time photography came to prominence (and was experimented with widely by the two). World War II and the Cold-War era saw a fusion of such abstract concepts with the flat black, red and whites of Moor’s work, with a focus on the concept of “Social Realism” enforced by Stalin's regime; the use of art only as a means to convey data, as opposed to art for art’s sake.
[Left] A peice of experimental artwork by Rodchenko. [Right] One of Lissitsky's most famous (and in fact his last) posters, inspiring the Soviet population to build more equipment for the army during WWII.
From this research, I took note of the aspects that were common throughout. Shapes were kept simple and usually flat coloured, with minimal block shading of a contrasting colour. Caricatures of Soviet people were usually in strong, stoic poses, and drawn with blocky, straight lines, while their enemies are usually depicted in grotesque or monstrous forms, designed to amplify their negative aspects and reinforce feelings of them being inhuman.
With these notes, as well as minor research into other examples of propaganda work (such as WWII propaganda posters from America, Britain and Germany, and modern Vietnam and Chinese posters), I was then able to look back over my project and see how it could be redesigned to make use of these concepts.