4 Nov 2009

Week 2 – First presentation & Comments:

Week 2 saw us present our concepts to both our tutor and rest of the group; a good opportunity to see one-another progress, exchange ideas and give recommendations on one another’s work. I was also hoping to use this presentation to interest classmates who were not yet in a final group, and hopefully gain their assistance on the project.

As my turn came to give a presentation, i found there were mixed reactions to the concept. There was interest in the edutainment idea, agreement that Unreal could achieve the lighting and first person camera results the project aimed for, and on the avoidance of realism in the game.

However, many did not feel the Anime style and Japanese cultural references (namely the Neko character) suited the project, fearing that it was an overused style, and the links to the genre it would bring through its use would ‘drown out’ the morals and deeper meaning the game is trying to get across to the player, preventing the game from achieving its objective. Some also voiced confusion as to the game’s mechanics and whether the character described, an untrained, weapon less civilian, would react to the situation with the slow, stealthy, Splinter Cell-esque manoeuvres the game used. Our tutor also felt the project focused too heavily on storyline, and suggested I consider a game design without any story consideration, so as to maximise the impact of the message I am trying to convey. (In hindsight, I also imagine my presentation was not helped by the extremely large amount of information I attempted to cram into the short presentation time. In future I need to be more selective with my presentation material, avoiding deep descriptions and focusing on only the bare essentials.

Another major hurdle I noticed was the fact that most of the group had already decided upon their groups and their projects decided upon. The specifications of this project assumed I would be coordinating a group, and with it now likely I will be alone, I am no longer confident that the project will be achievable. I have come to the conclusion that I must decide quickly either to continue the project, or abandon the idea completely and see if another of the groups require more members.

No comments:

Post a Comment